The Vintage Eye: What to Look For at Estate Sales & Thrift Stores
- Vivienne Cookmeyer
- Mar 26
- 3 min read
There’s something magical about stepping into an estate sale or wandering through the aisles of a thrift store. Each piece has a history, a story to tell, and perhaps even a second life waiting for it in your home. But how do you separate the true treasures from the ordinary? Whether you're a seasoned collector or a curious newcomer, developing a keen vintage eye is the key to uncovering hidden gems. Here’s what to keep in mind on your next treasure hunt.
1. Recognizing Quality & Value
When browsing, always check for craftsmanship and historical significance. Solid wood furniture, hand-stitched textiles, and real leather often stand the test of time better than mass-produced alternatives. Look for dovetail joints in furniture, sterling silver markings on flatware, and labels that indicate handmade or limited-run pieces. Additionally, certain time periods produced particularly valuable and well-crafted items—Mid-century modern furniture, Art Deco jewelry, and Depression glass are just a few styles that remain highly sought after. Flip items over and check for markings, signatures, or labels from well-known designers like Stickley, Eames, or Pyrex, as these brands hold strong resale value. Vintage clothing enthusiasts should look for union tags to help date a garment and indicate quality craftsmanship.
2. Rare & Unusual Finds
Some of the best treasures are the unexpected ones. Quirky artwork, antique holiday decorations, or unusual collectibles can be worth a second look. Unique items often attract collectors and can make for great conversation pieces in your home.
3. Condition Matters
While patina adds character, major damage can diminish an item’s value. Check for cracks, missing pieces, stains, or significant wear before purchasing. That said, some items—like solid wood furniture—can often be restored with a little effort.
4. Think Beyond the Obvious
Estate sales and thrift stores are great places to find not only vintage decor but also high-end kitchenware, tools, books, and even designer handbags. Keep an open mind and explore sections you might normally overlook.
You can also consider repurposing vintage items in creative ways. An old ladder can become a bookshelf, vintage suitcases can be stacked into a unique side table, and antique frames can be turned into mirrors or add character to your collage wall. Thinking outside the box can breathe new life into forgotten pieces and add unique character to your home.
5. Finding Artwork
Art can be one of the most overlooked but valuable finds at estate sales and thrift stores. Look for original paintings, signed prints, or limited-edition pieces. Check the back of the artwork for artist signatures, gallery stickers, or other identifying marks. Older frames can also be valuable, sometimes even more so than the artwork itself. In our opinion, the best art is the original stuff that you find at estate sales. We pick up original artwork framed and unframed at almost every sale we go to.
6. Trust Your Instincts
If something speaks to you, don’t hesitate too long! Estate sales especially operate on a first-come, first-served basis. If you love an item and the price is right, trust your gut and make the purchase—you may not get a second chance.
7. Stay Educated
The more you learn, the better your eye becomes. Follow vintage and antique forums, read collector guides, and attend estate sales regularly to sharpen your knowledge.
Developing a vintage eye takes time, but the thrill of finding something special makes it all worthwhile. Next time you’re at an estate sale or thrift store, keep these tips in mind—you never know what hidden treasure you might uncover!
Stay tuned for next week's podcast where we will take a deep dive into the Vintage Eye and what we look out for at sales!
As always, Stay Golden!
-Sharifah & Viv
Comments